Complain about a product or service

IRS Plans to Yank Tax-Exempt Status of 20 Credit Counselors

October 13, 2005
Just as the new bankruptcy law is about to require that counsumers sign up for credit counseling before they can file for bankruptcy, the Internal Revenue Service is cracking down on non-profit credit-counseling firms.

Credit Counseling • FTC Charges Home Buying Operation With Credit Repair Scheme • FTC Charges Express Consolidation Misleads Consumers • Debt Free Agrees to West Virginia Refunds • Ohio Sues "Credit Counselor" For Deceiving, Threatening Consumers • Debt Management Telemarketers Settle FTC Charges • FTC Shuts Down 20 "Credit Repair" Schemes • FTC Sues "Debt Elimination" Programs • AmeriDebt Founder Settles FTC Charges for $35 Million • IRS Plans to Yank Tax-Exempt Status of 20 Credit Counselors • IRS Revokes Tax-Exempt Status of Four Credit Counseling Agencies • Three Debt Management Firms Settle Federal Charges • AmeriDebt To Close as Part of FTC Settlement • Credit Counseling Riddled With Fast-Buck Promoters, Congress Finds • Credit Counselors Not Always What They Seem • Credit Counseling Scams On the Rise • Lenders Ratchet Down Payments to Credit Counselors --- • More about Credit Counseling

The Washington Post reported that the IRS plans to revoke the tax-exempt status of about 20 large credit-counseling firms that account for about half the industry's revenues. The agency has been auditing 40 counseling firms and expects to audit another 20 when the current round of examinations is finished, the Post said.

The credit-counseling industry has been a sore point with many consumer advocates for years. There are few specific regulations governing credit counselors and many supposedly non-profit firms do little more than act as collection agencies for banks and credit card companies, which traditionally pay all or some of their fees.

The IRS warned credit counselors earlier this year that it was taking a close look at whether non-profit firms were putting their clients' interests first or whether they were acting as businesses intent on making a profit from every transaction.

"It's basic bread-and-butter tax-exempt law ... You help people, you don't hurt people," IRS attorney Debra Kawecki told members of the Association of Independent Consumer Credit Counseling Agencies at its annual meeting in July.

As the IRS crackdown continues, it's likely consumers desperate to file for bankruptcy will have a hard time finding an approved credit counselor to work with them. The Justice Department, which administers the bankruptcy program, is developing a list of approved firms and so far has approved 41 applications out of about 200.

Those that have been approved have been hiring new counselors in hopes of meeting the anticipated demand. Most will be offering counseling via telephone and the Internet as well as in person.

One potential sticking point is that the IRS and the Justice Department are not communicating with each other, since the IRS is not permitted to divulge information about firms it is auditing. That leaves open the possibility that the Justice Department will approve a counseling firm only to have the IRS revoke its tax-exempt status.

Credit-counseling firms are not required to be non-profit but most are.

Report Your Experience
If you've had a bad experience -- or a good one -- with a consumer product or service, we'd like to hear about it. All complaints are reviewed by class action attorneys and are considered for publication on our site. Knowledge is power! Help spread the word. File your consumer report now.

Back to the top |