Complain about a product or service

FCC Takes Another Look at Net Neutrality

By Martin H. Bosworth
ConsumerAffairs.com

March 23, 2007

Net Neutrality • FCC Votes To Create Net Neutrality Rules • FCC Chairman Proposes New Net Neutrality Rules • FCC Launches Probe Of Wireless Industry • FCC Chair Vows To Enforce Net Neutrality • House Introduces "Internet Freedom Preservation Act" • Obama Promises Support for Cybersecurity, Net Neutrality • Net Neutrality Advocate Tapped As FCC Head • Internet Providers Ponder Bandwidth Limits For Heavy Users • Comcast, Cox Caught Blocking BitTorrent • Will Antitrust Law Save Net Neutrality? • Few Are Neutral in Net Neutrality Battles • Net Neutrality Supporters Testify • Comcast Blocks Public From FCC Hearing • Congress Gets Net Neutrality Legislation • Time Warner To Test Metered Pricing For Broadband • House Committee To Probe FCC • FCC To Investigate Comcast For Blocking Net Traffic • Verizon Wireless Opens Network to All Devices, Software • Comcast Sued Over Internet Blocking • Verizon Overrides Internet Searches With Its Own Results • Comcast Blocks Subscribers From Some Services • Verizon's Abortion Block Raises Net Neutrality Concerns • FTC Nixes Net Neutrality • Wireless Spectrum May Hold Key To Net Neutrality • Telcos Lift Block On FreeConference.Com • FCC Takes Another Look at Net Neutrality • AT&T Blocks Calls To Competing Conference Call Service • Study: Ending Net Neutrality Would Hurt Consumers • FCC, FTC Challenged To Protect Net Neutrality • Net Neutrality Back on Congress' Agenda • Net Neutrality Opponents Step Up PR Blitz • AT&T Trumpets New TV Service • Verizon Joins BellSouth in Retreat From Unexplained New DSL Fee • FCC Nudges BellSouth Into Giving Up New DSL Fees • FTC Head Urges "Caution" On Net Neutrality • Net Neutrality May Derail Telecom Bill • Google: No Net Neutrality Means Antitrust Fight • Senate Prepares for Net Neutrality Showdown • Congress Moves Quickly To Satisfy Telecoms' Net Neutrality, Cable Entry Demands • Net Neutrality Gets Its Day In Congress • Net Neutrality Wins Committee Vote In Congress • Net Neutrality Attracts Surprising Allies • Congress Wrestles with Net Neutrality

The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) has announced a formal Notice of Inquiry into the behavior and practices of players in the broadband Internet market. The inquiry, the agency said, will investigate how broadband providers are living up to the FCC's promise of encouraging broadband development and promoting "the open and interconnected nature of the public Internet."

The FCC said its inquiry would also explore adopting the principles of "nondiscrimination" of Internet traffic, commonly called "net neutrality," and how to define the principle if adopted.

The battle over net neutrality has shaped up as a hot-button political issue in the last year, with content providers and Internet activists claiming that major telecom and cable companies would use their market clout to force companies like Google and Yahoo to pay extra money to promote their services, and that services favored by certain companies would get priority "traffic rights" over others.

"Gathering this information will allow us to better monitor this market and determine the extent to which providers are acting consistently with our Internet Policy Statement," said FCC chair Kevin Martin. "We have the dual responsibilities of creating an environment that promotes infrastructure investment and broadband deployment and to ensure that consumers' access to content on the Internet is protected."

The "Internet Policy Statement" consists of four principles adopted by the FCC under previous chairman Michael Powell. The principles included the rights of consumers to have lawful access to the Internet, to attach devices and run applications that are legal and cause no harm, and to enjoy competition among service providers. The policy statement lacked any concrete options for enforcement in cases where the principles were not upheld.

FCC commissioner Michael Copps criticized the Policy Statement for not going far enough.

"We proceed too leisurely here," he said. "Rather than strike out and unflinchingly proclaim this agency's commitment to an open and non-discriminatory Internet, we satisfy ourselves with one tiny, timid step," Copps said. "We adopted our Four Principles of Internet Freedom nearly two years ago. And these issues come back to us in just about every major merger that comes before us—and there have been a lot of those!"

Copps, along with fellow commissioner Jonathan Adelstein, opposed the mega-merger of AT&T and BellSouth until AT&T agreed to offer concessions to protect net neutrality for its basic Internet services for 36 months.

AT&T has been one of the primary foes of net neutrality, with chairman Ed Whitacre famously claiming that companies like Google were "nuts" for not paying extra money to use his "pipes." After the concessions were offered, the merger was hurriedly approved on Dec. 29, 2006.

Since then, AT&T has come under fire for blocking calls made using the FreeConference.Com multiple calling service, claiming the calls violated its own terms of service. Opponents claim that AT&T is blocking services its subscribers are legally eligible to access, and point to this as an example of the need for net neutrality rules.

FCC chair Martin has been criticized by consumer groups and Congress for being too friendly to the needs of telecom companies over consumer interests. Martin was grilled at a recent House committee hearing for supporting new FCC rules that streamline video franchising rights for new companies trying to offer video services in neighborhoods. Critics charge that the new rules override state and local authority and favor telecom companies' new video offerings at the expense of existing cable services.

Martin's predecessor Powell recently signed on to the board of directors of Cisco Networks. Cisco has been a staunch opponent of net neutrality, as it stands to gain from selling network systems capable of prioritizing Internet traffic and offering faster services to richer clients.

Cisco's Bob Pepper -- himself a former FCC official -- recently penned an editorial lambasting net neutrality rules as "the wrong path of reduced competition, less consumer choice and greater government involvement and oversight."

A recent study conducted by University of Florida professor Kenneth Cheng found that ending net neutrality would harm consumers and companies alike. Companies would lose incentive to prioritize content and offer better service if the current infrastructure was upgraded, and content providers would have to pay extra fees to service providers to ensure their offerings were seen by viewers. Consumers would also lose by not being exposed to Web content they might have interest in, due to slower page load times and service.

Report Your Experience
If you've had a bad experience -- or a good one -- with a consumer product or service, we'd like to hear about it. All complaints are reviewed by class action attorneys and are considered for publication on our site. Knowledge is power! Help spread the word. File your consumer report now.

Share		Follow us on Twitter.

Back to the top |