Complain about a product or service

Effectiveness Of Activity-Promoting Video Games Measured

Non-'couch potato' games shown to have some health benefits

By James Limbach
ConsumerAffairs.com

September 19, 2009

• Can Active Video Games Help Prevent Obesity? • Effectiveness Of Activity-Promoting Video Games Measured • Final Fantasy Suit Alleges Hidden Fees, Penalties • California Petitions Supreme Court To Enforce Video Game Law • Study Suggests Video Games Are Addictive • Video Games Blamed For Poor Family Relationships • Researchers Study Wii's Impact on Fitness • Kids Burn More Calories Playing Active Video Games • Study Questions Effect of Violent Video Games • Active Video Games No Substitute for Exercise • Why Are Men More into Gamesmanship? • Study Measures Impact of Media Violence • Manhunt 2: Pushing the Limit of Gore and Violence • Kids Spending More Time Playing Video Games • Parents Urged To Monitor Kids' Video Games • Fight Over Manhunt 2 Could Get Nasty • The Addictiveness of Virtual Violence • Study: Video Games May Sharpen Vision • Mayo Clinic Study Endorses Concept Behind Nintendo's Wii • Researchers Find Video Games Addicting • Report Finds Progress in Keeping Violent Video Games Out of Kids' Hands • Researcher Urges Parents To Reconsider Giving Video Games • Violent Video Games Leave Teens Emotionally Aroused --- Hardware & Programs • Is Nintendo's Wii Really Good Exercise? • Nintendo Wii: The Buzz Goes On • Nintendo Says It Can’t Meet Wii Holiday Demand • Injuries Grow Along With Wii Popularity • Nintendo's Wii Spreads Mayhem as Wiimote Goes Flying • Nintendo Sued Over Broken Wii Strap • Nintendo Recalls Straps For Wii Controller • Gamers Favoring Wii over PS3 • Nintendo Purchasers Complain of Gamesmanship • Nintendo, Sony Offer Competing Visions Of Video Games • PlayStation 3 Takes the Field • PlayStation 3 Brings Big Bucks on eBay • Gamers Complain "Dead Rising" Fatal to Microsoft Xbox

A recent study by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Emory University and Andrews University reported that adult video gamers suffer higher levels of depression and weigh more than non-gamers.

In fact, researchers found in the study of 562 adults (ages 19 to 90) from the Seattle-Tacoma, Wash. area, that there were "measurable correlations between video game playing and health risks."

But those results reflect people who were playing traditional, sedentary video games. Today's activity-promoting video games -- such as Wii Fit, EA SPORTS Active and Dance Dance Revolution -- may be changing all that. That's the conclusion of Lorraine Lanningham-Foster, an Iowa State University assistant professor of food science and human nutrition, who is conducting research on the measurable health benefits of the more active games.

Lanningham-Foster was lead author of a study titled "Activity-Promoting Video Games and Increased Energy Expenditure," which was published in the The Journal of Pediatrics. The research on 22 children, ages 10 to 14, found that a child who plays eight hours of video games a week will burn 1,990 calories (an average of 284 per day) through Nintendo Wii Boxing -- or three times as many as the 652 calories they'd burn playing a traditional sedentary video game.

More calories burned

"What I wanted to demonstrate was how many more calories your body can burn by playing Wii as opposed to playing a traditional video game -- and it's quite a lot," said Lanningham-Foster, who conducted the National Institutes of Health-funded research while she was employed in the Endocrine Research Unit at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn.

"Even with the Wii boxing game in the training mode, we can get people to basically triple -- and sometimes more -- the number of calories they burn, relative to if they were playing a more traditional video game," she said.

Not everyone is singing the praises of Wii:

• Debbie of Corpus Christi, Texas, tells ConsumerAffairs.com that her elbow began swelling after playing. "I went to the emergency room, had it checked out and I have a severe strain, and the doctor injected some kind of cortisone injection in the elbow. I just wanted to report this so it would be on record of the possible injuries from the Wii"

• Jackie of Bedford in the United Kingdom wrote us, saying "I brought the Nintendo Wii remote control charge station, I plugged it into the Wii as instructed, a week later it started to make a buzzing noise, then my son discovered that the remotes were very hot, and no longer worked."

Family that plays together ...

Because Wii games allow for multiple players, Lanningham-Foster is now studying the health benefits for families who play the games together at home. She began screening potential subjects this month for the study, which is funded by ISU's Nutrition and Wellness Research Center.

The ISU researcher will ask the families to play video games on the Wii system in their homes for two weeks. She'll then analyze the amount of movement and the number of calories burned by each family member to determine the game's overall health benefit.

"What we do is some high-precision measurements of their [family members'] energy expenditure, using devices they wear to monitor physical activity and through a technique called doubly-labeled water [enriching water with more hydrogen and oxygen than what's normally found in nature] -- which is really the gold standard method in the field -- to measure how many calories they burn," she said. "And then I give them a Nintendo Wii and certain games to play -- Wii Fit, which has been out now for more than a year and was one of the first that really made people more aware of their body weight and physical activity; and EA Active, which is more designed for adults as a way to get them in the workout mode in their homes."

While the results aren't yet in, Lanningham-Foster already sees the games providing families some low-cost home fitness options.

Her primary research is also focused on prevention and intervention of pediatric obesity and she says the new video games are a fun way for kids to become more active.

"Kids don't think like adults do -- that they need to go to the gym and work out and be healthier," she said. "I don't think those concepts really come into play. If they're having fun and they're moving [by playing activity-promoting video games], that's the most that they want to do."

Report Your Experience
If you've had a bad experience -- or a good one -- with a consumer product or service, we'd like to hear about it. All complaints are reviewed by class action attorneys and are considered for publication on our site. Knowledge is power! Help spread the word. File your consumer report now.

Share		Follow us on Twitter.