Bath Fitter vs. Re-Bath

Bath Fitter vs. Re-Bath: Which is better?

Re-Bath and Bath Fitter both provide innovative solutions for people who are looking for a bathroom remodeling contractor. Bath Fitter focuses on quick, affordable bathroom updates, often installing acrylic bathtub liners and shower surrounds in as little as one day. Re-Bath offers more extensive remodeling services, including full bathroom renovations, walk-in tubs and upgrades to fixtures, cabinets and countertops.

Products available	Tub and shower surrounds, safety additions, accessories, wall and ceiling enhancements	Tubs and showers, wall surrounds, cabinets, countertops, toilets, faucets, lighting, hardware
Services	Bathroom updates and tub/shower installation	Bathroom renovation and redesign
Demolition required	No	May be required
Material options	Acrylic only	Acrylic and stone
Design consultant	Yes	Yes
Level of customization	Limited	Extensive
Timeline	1-day installation	Multiple days

	Products available	Services	Demolition required	Material options	Design consultant	Level of customization	Timeline
	Tub and shower surrounds, safety additions, accessories, wall and ceiling enhancements	Bathroom updates and tub/shower installation	No	Acrylic only	Yes	Limited	1-day installation
	Tubs and showers, wall surrounds, cabinets, countertops, toilets, faucets, lighting, hardware	Bathroom renovation and redesign	May be required	Acrylic and stone	Yes	Extensive	Multiple days

Bath Fitter

Bath Fitter is primarily known for bathtub liners and tub-to-shower conversions. The company installs prefabricated liners over existing tubs, offering a quicker and more budget-friendly remodeling option. There’s no demolition or risk of damage that can leave your bathroom out of commission for multiple days.

However, this approach does not address issues with surrounding bathroom fixtures. Bath Fitter does offer additional solutions for walls, wainscoting and accessory renovations, but these aren’t the main thrust of their operation.

If you’re looking to make safety updates such as grab bars, shower seats or hand-held shower heads, Bath Fitter provides plenty of options. They also provide services for those looking to turn an existing shower/tub combo into a shower only.

Bath Fitter pricing

Bath Fitter’s costs vary based on the project type, bathroom size, upgrades and location. Bath Fitter doesn't publish standard pricing on its website but offers free consultations for personalized estimates.  

Tub liners typically cost between $5,000 and $10,000, while tub-to-shower conversions range from $5,000 to $7,500. Based on customer reviews, many homeowners receive quotes around $10,000.

Financing options are also available, including low monthly payments and promotional 0% interest offers.

Bath Fitter warranty

Bath Fitter offers a lifetime warranty on all of its acrylic products. The warranty applies to the original purchaser, as well as any subsequent homeowners. 

Maintaining Bath Fitter’s warranty requires that you only use cleaning products on an approved list, which can be referenced on the company’s website. You must also be prepared to show proof of purchase to simplify your warranty claims that may arise.

Re-Bath

Re-Bath offers more comprehensive bathroom renovations. The company can replace your existing bathtub or shower, including walk-in tubs, tub-to-shower conversions and accessibility upgrades. These solutions typically come with a higher price tag, but also do more to remodel your entire bathroom.

Re-Bath also provides consumers with a five-year guarantee on their products. If you are looking for a complete remodel, Re-Bath gives you options for everything from cabinets and countertops to bathroom lighting, bath wall surrounds and all aspects of your new bathroom design down to the hardware.

Re-Bath contractors assist you with deciding the best choice — a full remodel or simple upgrades — and help you move forward with the best option for your space.

Re-Bath pricing

Re-Bath remodeling costs vary depending on the size of your bathroom, the extent of the renovation and the materials you choose. A tub liner typically costs between $5,000 and $10,000, while a bathtub or shower replacement or conversion ranges from $10,000 to $18,000. For a full bathroom remodel, expect to pay between $25,000 and $30,000.

Re-Bath offers free in-home consultations to help homeowners explore their options and receive a personalized quote. Because Re-Bath locations are independently owned and operated, pricing and available services may vary by location.

Re-Bath warranty

Re-Bath offers warranties on all its products and services. DuraBath acrylic products, including liners, wall surrounds and accessories, come with a lifetime warranty. This covers labor costs for repairs or replacements due to manufacturing defects.

DuraBath natural stone products come with a 10-year limited warranty. Walk-in tubs’ frames, shells and door gaskets come with a lifetime warranty, while components like faucets and trim kits have a 5-year warranty.

Re-Bath also offers a one-year warranty on the workmanship and installation of your entire bathroom remodel project.

Bath Fitter vs. Re-Bath warranty

Both companies offer lifetime warranties on acrylic products, but Re-Bath also provides coverage for natural stone products and installation workmanship. Here’s a comparison of Bath Fitter and Re-Bath’s warranties side by side.

Bath Fitter vs. Re-Bath: Which should you choose?

Choosing between Bath Fitter and Re-Bath comes down to your budget, your renovation timetable and your bathroom remodeling needs.

Choose Bath Fitter if...

• You want a quick, one-day installation.
• You're looking for a budget-friendly update.
• You want to avoid extensive demolition.
• You only need to update your tub or shower.

Bath Fitter is perfect if you’re looking to refresh your bathtub or shower quickly and without much hassle. On top of a fresh new look, you can add safety features like shower seats and grab bars in just one day. 

Bath Fitter customers praise the company for its speed, cleanliness and timeliness. A reviewer in Michigan described a crew that "worked 9 non-stop hours" and kept dust to a minimum while replacing both a tub and shower, while a customer in Washington called their installers "personable, professional and a perfectionist in each step of removal, rebuild, and install," adding that everything was "left spotless.”

Bath Fitter’s options come with a much lower price tag than most bathroom remodeling options as well. So if you’re looking for a convenient way to remodel your bathroom without breaking the bank, Bath Fitter is the best option for you.

Choose Re-Bath if...

• You want a complete bathroom remodel.
• You need extensive accessibility upgrades.
• You prefer more design and material options.
• You have a larger budget and flexible timeline.

Re-Bath is perfect if you’re looking to overhaul your entire bathroom, especially if you need greater accessibility options to address limited mobility. With more customization options for bathtubs, showers and everything else you find in a bathroom, Re-Bath can completely revamp not just the safety of your bathroom, but also the style. 

Similar to Bath Fitter, Re-Bath’s positive reviews cluster around skilled individual installers and crews who get the job done efficiently and respectfully. A customer in South Carolina praised an installer whose "professionalism is outstanding... making sure each panel fits before applying the sealant," with plumbing "properly sealed" and doors that "operate smoothly.”

The negative end of the spectrum, however, surfaces recurring and serious complaints: botched installations, leaking showers, pooling water and warranties that turn out to be far less comprehensive than advertised. In Massachusetts, a reviewer learned the hard way that the "lifetime warranty" excluded workmanship issues, noting bitterly that "cracks are the only thing covered.”

The more comprehensive remodeling through Re-Bath also means that your bathroom will likely be out of commission for a few days and that your bill will be significantly higher than with Bath Fitter.

FAQ